From Recipe Box 151

Classic Butter Icing Recipe

The original, as found. Tap to see it larger.

About this recipe

Recipe box
Box 151

This butter icing recipe comes straight from a vintage collection, making it a delightful choice for those who appreciate old-fashioned desserts. Butter icing is a simple, creamy frosting made with just a few pantry staples. Its light and sweet flavor complements cakes and other baked goods perfectly. The creamy texture comes from the butter, while the sugar provides the sweetness that balances the icing. You can easily adjust it with flavors like vanilla, cream, or even melted chocolate for a richer taste. Whether you’re topping a birthday cake or a simple batch of cupcakes, this butter icing recipe is a must-have for any home baker’s repertoire.

Join our Vintage Recipe Facebook Group to discuss and find “new” old recipes to enjoy.

Links to find other recipes:

Butter Icing

Butter Icing

Food History

Butter icing, or buttercream, has been a popular topping for cakes and pastries for over a century. The use of butter in frostings gained popularity in the 19th century when butter became more accessible due to improvements in dairy farming. Before then, icings were often made with just sugar and water. With the invention of powdered sugar, buttercream frosting became easier to make, leading to its widespread use in baking. This type of frosting is particularly common in American and European desserts. Variations of butter icing, such as Swiss meringue or French buttercream, can also be found in many classic pastry recipes. The addition of milk or cream to this vintage recipe brings a creamier texture, while optional flavorings like vanilla or melted chocolate offer a delicious twist. This icing pairs perfectly with simple sponge cakes or rich chocolate layers, making it versatile for many desserts.

Timeline

  • 1700s: Early forms of icing included egg whites and sugar.
  • 1800s: Buttercream began appearing in more refined European cakes.
  • 1900s: Powdered sugar became widely available, making preparing butter icing easier.
  • Mid-1900s: This recipe, likely from the mid-20th century, reflects traditional American home baking.

Recipe Discussion

This butter icing recipe is incredibly versatile. It starts with creaming butter and confectioners’ sugar, creating a light and fluffy base. Adding milk, cream, or hot water helps you achieve the desired consistency, making it smooth and easy to spread. You can adjust the thickness based on your preference by adding more liquid for a softer spread or less for a thicker texture. The recipe also allows room for flavor variations. Vanilla is a classic choice, but you could also add melted chocolate or nut extracts for a different flavor. The filling option, with whipped cream and chopped nuts, adds richness and texture, perfect for layer cakes. The combination of butter and sugar creates a balanced sweetness that enhances the overall taste of any dessert. This icing is best paired with simple cake flavors like vanilla or chocolate, though it also works well on cupcakes, cookies, and other baked treats.

Preparation Tips

  • Soften the butter before starting, making it easier to cream with the sugar.
  • Use a hand mixer or stand mixer to get a smooth and fluffy texture for the icing.
  • Add the confectioners’ sugar slowly to avoid lumps.
  • If the icing is too thick, add more milk, cream, or even a little hot water, one teaspoon at a time.
  • If the icing is too thin, add more powdered sugar until you reach the desired thickness.
  • For a richer flavor, consider adding 2 squares of melted chocolate.
  • The optional filling (whipped cream and chopped nuts) can be made ahead of time to allow the flavors to meld.
  • Ensure the cake is completely cool before spreading the icing to prevent melting.
  • This recipe yields enough icing for a standard 9-inch cake or about 12 cupcakes.

Recommended Kitchen Products

The links below lead to top-rated products on Amazon—if you use our links, we can save more recipes.

  • Hand Mixer: A good hand mixer will help you achieve a smooth and creamy butter icing in less time.
  • Offset Spatula: Perfect for spreading icing evenly on cakes without causing damage to delicate surfaces.
  • Mixing Bowls: Sturdy mixing bowls with a non-slip base will make creaming butter and sugar much easier.

Serving Suggestions

  • Spread this butter icing over a classic vanilla or chocolate cake.
  • Use it to top cupcakes for an extra creamy treat.
  • Pair it with sponge cake or pound cake for a simple, elegant dessert.
  • Add food coloring to match holiday themes or party decorations.
  • Spread between layers of cake with fruit preserves for added flavor.
  • Mix with melted chocolate for a rich chocolate buttercream.

A Perfectly Sweet Addition

Butter icing remains one of the most versatile frostings, perfect for any baking project. Its simple ingredients and easy-to-follow instructions make it a go-to choice for new and experienced bakers. The smooth, creamy texture and light sweetness enhance cakes, cupcakes, and cookies. For those looking to add a bit of nostalgia to their kitchen, this recipe offers a timeless way to dress up desserts. You can customize it with your favorite flavors or keep it classic with vanilla. Whether you’re preparing a birthday cake or a special treat for the weekend, this butter icing recipe will surely impress.

Butter Icing Recipe

Butter Icing

Butter Icing

This classic butter icing recipe is a vintage delight, perfect for frosting cakes, cupcakes, and cookies. Made with simple ingredients like butter, confectioners' sugar, and optional vanilla, it's easy to prepare and customize. The recipe includes an optional filling of whipped cream, melted chocolate, and chopped nuts, making it ideal for layer cakes. Smooth, creamy, and perfectly sweet, this butter icing is a must-have for any home baker's collection.

No Ratings

Ingredients

Icing

  • 1 ½ cups confectioners’ sugar
  • ½ cup butter
  • ½ teaspoon vanilla (if desired)

Filling for Cake

  • To the butter icing, add:
  • 2 squares melted chocolate
  • ¼ cup whipped cream
  • ½ cup chopped nut meats

Instructions

  1. Cream butter.
  2. Add sugar.
  3. Add flavoring and milk, cream, or hot water until the right consistency to spread.

More recipes from Box 151

Flip through the whole box

More dessert recipes

See them all

Do you know this handwriting?

If this recipe looks like one from your family’s kitchen, or you grew up eating this, tell us below.

Leave a memory

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.